| Tevye, a dairyman | Stuart Pace |
| Golde, his wife | Jackie Robb |
| Tzeitel | Kerry Maher |
| Hodel | Megan Taylor |
| Chava | Julia Knitel |
| Shprintze | Sarah Vaughan |
| Bielke | Lynn Messina |
| Yente, a matchmaker | Peggy Long |
| Motel, a tailor | Jody Laufer |
| Shandel, his mother | |
| Perchik, a student | Bobby Kalman |
| Lazar Wolf, a butcher | John Fleming |
| Mordcha, an innkeeper | Doug Vaughan |
| Esther, his wife | JoAnne Vaughan |
| Rabbi | Marty Herrman |
| Mendel, his son | Jared Rochman |
| Avram, a bookseller | Steve Taylor |
| Nahum, a beggar | Adam Polisi |
| Grandma Tzeitel, Golde’s Grandmother | Nancy Quinn |
| Fruma Sarah, Lazar Wolf’s first wife | Robin Popielarz |
| Yussel, a hatter | Brandon Colon |
| Constable | Jim Quinlan |
| Fyedka, a young man | Evan Menist |
| Sasha, his friend | Terrance Dolan |
| Sergei, Sasha’s brother | Brendan Dolan |
| The Fiddler | Phil Sloves |
| The Villagers | |
| Kristoff | Chad Colacurcio |
| Rifka | |
| Aviva | Paola Joosten |
| Fish Seller | Diana Walsh |